Why Do I Shut Down When Things Get Too Much?
Why Do I Shut Down When Things Get Too Much?
Have you ever been in the middle of a difficult conversation and suddenly found that you have nothing to say?
Not because you don't care. Not because you don't have thoughts or feelings about what's happening. In fact, quite often it's the opposite.
There's too much happening.
Your mind goes blank. You become quiet. Perhaps you need to leave the room. Someone asks what you're thinking and the only honest answer you can give is, “I don't know.”
Then, an hour later, or perhaps the following day, the words arrive.
You know exactly what you wanted to say.
So why couldn't you say it when it mattered?
Sometimes shutting down is your mind trying to cope
When we feel threatened, our bodies have some remarkably effective ways of trying to protect us.
Most people have heard of fight or flight. When our brain senses danger, our nervous system prepares us either to confront that danger or escape from it.
But there's another response that perhaps gets talked about less: freeze.
And the “danger” doesn't have to be somebody chasing us down the street.
For some people, conflict can feel threatening. So can criticism, rejection, feeling misunderstood, being confronted with somebody else's strong emotions or simply having too many things happening at once.
Your rational mind might know you're standing in your kitchen having an argument with somebody you love.
Your nervous system isn't necessarily interested in rational explanations.
It has detected threat.
And it responds.
You might notice your heart beating faster. Your chest might tighten. You may struggle to concentrate. Perhaps you feel hot, shaky or strangely detached from what's happening.
And for some people, the words simply disappear.
You shut down.
“Why won't you just talk to me?”
This becomes particularly difficult in relationships.
Imagine one person desperately wants to resolve an argument.
They ask:
“What's wrong?”
The other person says:
“Nothing.”
“Clearly something's wrong.”
“I don't want to talk about it.”
“But we need to talk about it.”
And so the first person pushes a little harder.
Unfortunately, if the second person is already overwhelmed, that extra pressure may make it even harder for them to communicate.
They withdraw further.
The first person sees the withdrawal and thinks, You don't care.
So they push harder again.
One person is effectively saying:
“Please talk to me so that I know we're okay.”
The other is saying:
“Please give me some space so that I can become okay enough to talk.”
Neither necessarily wants to hurt the other.
They're simply trying to manage the same situation in completely different ways.
Where does shutting down come from?
There isn't one answer.
Sometimes we have to look at what somebody learned much earlier in life.
What happened when you expressed emotion growing up?
Were feelings talked about openly?
Could you disagree with the adults around you?
What happened when somebody became angry?
Were you comforted when you were upset, or were you expected to get over it?
Perhaps keeping quiet prevented arguments from becoming worse.
Perhaps you learnt that showing vulnerability wasn't safe.
Maybe you became the person who kept everybody else happy.
Or perhaps nobody ever really taught you how to identify what you were feeling, never mind explain it to somebody else.
If a way of responding helped us cope earlier in life, it makes sense that we might continue using it.
The problem is that something which once protected us can eventually start causing difficulties of its own.
Shutting down doesn't mean you don't care
I think this distinction is important.
People who shut down can sometimes appear cold or uninterested from the outside.
Inside, the experience may be completely different.
They may desperately want to explain themselves but can't organise their thoughts quickly enough.
They might be frightened of saying something they'll regret.
They may be trying to understand several emotions at once.
Or they might simply have reached their limit.
None of that means shutting down should become a way of avoiding every uncomfortable conversation.
Understanding a behaviour isn't the same as saying it can never change.
It simply gives us somewhere more useful to start.
Instead of asking:
“What's wrong with me?”
We can become curious about a different question:
“What happens to me when I begin to feel overwhelmed?”
Learn to recognise the moment before the shutdown
Often the shutdown itself isn't the beginning.
There may be warning signs.
Perhaps your shoulders tense.
You stop listening properly because you're preparing your response.
Your thoughts speed up — or suddenly disappear.
You feel the urge to leave.
You become defensive.
Your breathing changes.
You start saying “I don't care” when actually you care very much.
Learning to notice those early signs can be incredibly useful.
Because once you've completely shut down, communicating becomes much harder.
Catching yourself on the way there gives you more choices.
Taking time isn't the same as walking away
Sometimes the healthiest thing you can do during an overwhelming conversation is pause it.
But there's an important difference between taking some space and abandoning somebody in the middle of a difficult moment.
Instead of simply walking out, you might eventually learn to say:
“I want to talk about this, but I'm getting overwhelmed and I'm struggling to think. Can you give me half an hour and then we'll come back to it?”
That sentence communicates something very different from silence.
You're not saying:
“Your feelings don't matter.”
You're saying:
“This matters enough that I want to be able to have the conversation properly.”
And there's an important second part to that.
Come back.
If you repeatedly ask for space but never return to the conversation, the other person may understandably stop believing that you're taking time to regulate yourself and start experiencing it as avoidance.
Bringing yourself back into the room
When you notice yourself becoming overwhelmed, complicated techniques aren't always particularly helpful.
Sometimes simple things work better.
Slow your breathing.
Notice your feet against the floor.
Look around the room and consciously notice what you can see.
Have a drink of water.
Relax your jaw and shoulders.
Remind yourself:
I'm overwhelmed. I don't have to solve everything in this exact moment.
These things don't magically resolve whatever caused the difficulty.
What they can do is help your nervous system settle enough for the thinking part of your brain to come back online.
And once that happens, words often become easier to find.
You don't have to become brilliant at talking about feelings
There's another trap here.
Someone who has spent years keeping everything inside can decide they now need to become wonderfully emotionally articulate overnight.
That's an enormous expectation.
Start smaller.
Instead of explaining everything, perhaps begin with:
“I'm angry.”
“I'm hurt.”
“I feel embarrassed.”
“I'm frightened this is going to turn into an argument.”
Or even:
“I don't know what I'm feeling yet, but I know something is happening.”
That's communication.
You don't need the perfect words.
You just need somewhere to begin.
Becoming curious instead of critical
One of the things I value about counselling is that it gives us an opportunity to look at our patterns without immediately judging them.
Shutting down isn't necessarily a flaw that needs fixing.
It may be something you learnt to do for a very good reason.
But perhaps that response no longer serves you in the way it once did.
Counselling can provide somewhere to explore what happens when you become overwhelmed, what emotions are underneath the silence, where those patterns might have begun and, importantly, what you might want to do differently.
Because the aim isn't to make sure you never feel overwhelmed again.
Life probably isn't going to cooperate with that plan.
The aim is to understand yourself well enough that, when those moments come, you have more than one way of responding.
And perhaps, little by little, instead of disappearing from the conversation when things become difficult, you can learn how to remain part of it.
Kieran
Trust Counselling
Talk • Reflect • Move Forward
Comments